After a frustrating draw against Fulham on the opening weekend and a defeat to Everton last week, Fabian Hürzeler’s Brighton & Hove Albion finally picked up their first three points of the Premier League 2025/26 season—and they did it in spectacular fashion against Manchester City at the Amex Stadium.
It was a night to forget for Pep Guardiola’s side, who slumped to their second consecutive league defeat despite taking the lead through Erling Haaland. The Norwegian striker opened the scoring in the 33rd minute, netting his 88th goal in just his 100th appearance for City. His milestone strike looked set to put the champions on course for victory, but defensive lapses and costly errors saw the points slip away.
City Collapse After Dominant First Half
For much of the first half, Manchester City looked in control. With their trademark possession play and Haaland clinical in front of goal, the visitors carried a deserved 1-0 advantage into the break. But after halftime, City’s intensity dropped, and Brighton seized the momentum in front of their home fans.
Milner Sparks the Comeback
The turning point arrived in the 67th minute when Matheus Nunes handled the ball inside the box. The referee pointed to the spot, and veteran midfielder James Milner stepped up with composure to slot home the equaliser. The 39-year-old celebrated in Diogo Jota’s trademark style, dedicating the goal to his former Liverpool teammate.
From that moment, Brighton’s confidence soared. They pressed higher, forced mistakes, and refused to let City settle into rhythm.
Gruda Delivers the Winner
The decisive blow came in the 89th minute. Rising star Brajan Gruda produced a moment of brilliance, dribbling past City’s defense before calmly finishing past James Trafford to send the Amex into raptures.
Manchester City, despite enjoying over 65% possession, created few clear chances in the second half and looked vulnerable every time Brighton surged forward. Guardiola’s men were left stunned at the final whistle, suffering back-to-back defeats for the first time this season.
What Next for Guardiola and City?
With the international break looming, Manchester City will need to regroup quickly. Questions will be asked about their defensive frailties, midfield balance, and inability to convert dominance into results. For Brighton, this victory not only boosts confidence but also signals their intent to compete strongly under new boss Hürzeler.
The defeat leaves City chasing early ground in the Premier League title race, while Brighton climb the table with a morale-boosting win over the eight-time champions.